My daughter asked me to take her and a friend to the movies as part of her 15th birthday celebration, so naturally I said “Sure, what do you want to see?”
She said, “A movie about this surfer girl,” and I wondered what I had gotten myself into! Of course this wasn’t just any surfer girl and Soul Surfer is one of the finest films I’ve been fortunate enough to see!
To me a film needs three things to be great; the first is a great story.
Soul Surfer is the story of Bethany Hamilton, and hers is a truly great story. Ms Hamilton is the young surfer who at the age of thirteen lost an arm in a shark attack while training in Hawaii . Her injuries were severe and although she nearly died as a result, they kept her out of the water for only a few weeks. Soon she was surfing again, was able to compete and eventually fulfill her dream of turning pro. (And she is doing well as a pro). Ms Hamilton’s triumph is inspiring on par with the career of “Dummy” Hoy, the deaf baseball star of the early era of the game, Tom Dempsey’s record breaking 63 yard despite having only half of one of his feet, or Jim Abbott’s no hitter despite having just one hand. While all of these athletes had distinguished achievements, Hoy should be a hall of famer, and all are inspiring what separates Ms Hamilton is the fact she was not born with her “disability” but was presented with the challenge of relearning how to do everything with one arm, not just how to compete at the highest level of a challenging sport. To me the most inspiring aspect of Bethany Hamilton’s story is summed up in the words of Christ in John: 10:10The thief cometh not, but for to steal, and to kill, and to destroy: I am come that they might have life, and that they might have [it] more abundantly. If any one can testify of having something stolen and destroyed it would be Ms Hamilton moreover if any one is a testimony of what the abundant life of Christ really means it is this remarkable young woman! The wonderful peculiarity of Soul Surfer is that this part of the story comes through loud and clear. Hollywood is usually comfortable only with faith as it relates to a vague and unspecified deity, but the Hamilton family is Christian, their faith is in Jesus Christ, and the director and performers in the movie do a wonderful job of showing and modeling this faith. A home schooled girl who never gives her testimony without specifying that she gave her life to Jesus Christ at the age of five, in a family that goes to church and leans on the support of a youth minister who quotes from the Bible, in fact the Dad reads from the Bible (Phil. 4:13 from the NIV I can do everything through him who gives me strength.) These people are shown as normal folk achieving extraordinary things? And you thought Brokeback Mountain was revolutionary!
The second thing that makes a great movie is believability.
Realism and believability are not necessarily the same thing for example the 1933 version of King Kong is incredibly believable but not all that realistic, Soul Surfer is a true life story so realism does play heavily into the believability. The effects removing Annasophia Robb’s arm are flawless, the surfing, much of which is done by the real Ms Hamilton, is great and to my limited knowledge of the sport, the surfing competition seems realistic. Equally important is the scripting, if this story was told in platitude and cheesy dialogue with a few alligator tears thrown in it would hardly do justice to Ms Hamilton’s amazing story, but the script is tight, conversional, edgy and a little uncomfortable at times. You believe real people would talk this way. Finally you need to believe that the actors are the characters they portray and this movie has a heavy weight cast, in addition to Annasophia Robb as Bethany , Mr. and Mrs. Hamilton are played by Dennis Quaid and Helen Hunt, certainly pedigreed actors, Kevin Sorbo puts in a good turn as Bethany’s coach Holt Blanchard, and Carrie Underwood does a great job in her acting debut as Bethany’s youth leader Sarah Hill. The supporting roles are also all well done.
Finally a great film makes the audience care, it forms a connection, and does Soul Surfer ever do this.
One thing that impressed me with Soul Surfer was the directing. Going in most of us know that Bethany will be attacked by a shark so Sean McNamara does a fabulous job of setting up the incident so that when it does happen it’s a shock to the viewer. Also Bethany has setbacks and discouragements, though she never looses her faith, we are able to identify with her struggles. A few of the films more touching scenes involve Bethany ’s attempts to put others at ease about her injury. As a father I can identify most with Bethany ’s parents. All of us with teenagers struggle with the conflict between trying to help our kids and teaching them independence, letting them fall and helping them back up if you will. I can’t imagine if my daughter lost her arm!
In the end what Bethany Hamilton teaches us and what Soul Surfer conveys is that God does not know the meaning of the word limit, and that when we are weak His power is perfected in us.
My advice, don’t miss this one!
for more information check the official movie site.