Sunday, March 29, 2020

MAKING THE CURE WORSE THAN THE DISEASE


Do kids still read the Old Lady who swallowed a fly? When I was a kid I used to get my dear sainted mother to read that thing to me all the time. While it wasn’t my favorite, it couldn’t hold a candle to Rackety Boom or Bravest of All, it was always a good bedtime laugh. In the story the little old lady swallows a fly and in fear of the possibly mortal effects swallows progressively larger animals each as a cure for the other until she swallows a horse… she’s dead of course. I would love to send a copy to those folks in Washington DC and the various state capitals across the fruited plane because that silly rhyme is the closest example to the Covid 19 response I can think of.

Covid 19 or the Chinese Coronavirus is a serious thing and among vulnerable populations it can be deadly.  As of this writing 2,000 people have died and I would encourage prayer and support for the families of those victims, just as I would for the 24-64 thousand folks that influenza has claimed this year. Bottom line is we deal with the flu deaths every year despite having some highly touted and barely effective flu shot without crippling our economy and bankrupting our future.

Most states give governors power to take reasonable actions to deal with infectious disease, unfortunately the declaration of the state of emergencies has caused governors everywhere to suffer from the unfortunate delusion that they are Yul Brenner in the Ten Commandments as they decree “So Let it Be Written, So let it Be Done”   as they sign executive orders declaring who is essential and who is not. I can’t help but be reminded of Governor Kodos from the original Star Trek who ordered the deaths of nonessential colonists to save essential ones in a time of famine. Don’t laugh, these powers to temporarily shut down those businesses that Governor Ramses deems unworthy is exactly the power that the green new deal democrats want to have permanently, after all according to their experts global warming is far more dangerous than the Chinese coronavirus. Of course this temporary state of emergency isn’t the same as what the aforementioned Dems want but it is a huge step in that direction.

If our free election process survives, and I am certain it will, we the people must act to take back our liberties and seriously curtail the emergency powers we entrust our governors with. I do not doubt that the electoral process in our country will survive but it will not survive unscathed. The most sacred aspect of our democratic republic has also fallen under the whim of the Supreme Pharaohs of the several states, as 14 states have rescheduled their primaries based on Coronavirus fears, Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Wyoming and Puerto Rico.  The Governor of Ohio blatantly defied a court order forbidding him to do that very thing, imagine if Trump simply threw court orders out the window if he didn’t like their rulings? Surely I stipulate that these are primaries and are held at the discretion of parties and states, I am not suggesting that the President could use this as a justification to cancel national elections, but  it’s a big step in that direction.
We have already addressed the government hubris that defines the labeling of essential and nonessential businesses, but separately let’s address the asinine nature of these decisions. If you concede (and I do not) the authority of states to shutter private businesses at will it is impossible to justify the wisdom of the same. How does a bankrupting small business in Hiram Georgia stop the spread of infection in Manhattan? Perhaps these extreme measures are needed in hard hit areas but the strength of America in part is in our size and diversity. Droughts in the mid-west do not lead to famine because the same weather pattern may well produce a bumper crop in the Ohio Valley. New York City can be shut down by a terror attack but hundreds of other municipalities and cities can send resources to help them recover, the same is true of earthquakes in California, or floods in Tennessee. If we had a smart targeted response that allowed lightly affected and unaffected areas to continue to work and create wealth then the economic consequence would be minimized. Aid could be sent to places that need it, Americans would take care of Americans the way we do in every other crisis. Entrepreneurs would do what entrepreneurs do, they would find new ways to make money by fixing problems, rather motivated by altruistic or mercenary goals their solutions would be available. This is not to minimize what the private sector is doing in this crisis the advances in testing and treatment that have leapt from zero in just a few short weeks is phenomenal. Thankfully the President has resisted calls to nationalize industries and supply chains, and further tamp down the spirit of enterprise that will elevate us out of the dark times. Alas if we weren’t so dead set on crippling and destroying the economy and thus the ability of millions to contribute in big and small ways to abating the crisis what great things we could achieve!
Finally let’s remember that only about 10% of the crisis in this country is from the virus, 90% is the panic stricken responses. As we progressively swallow bigger and bigger animals to kill the fly we swallowed when we imported, through no fault of our own, this virus from China the horse that kills us may well be this relief effort passed by congress last week. 2.2 trillion dollars of new debt to do what churches (and oh do I have a lot to say about churches) and businesses should be doing without depleting the public treasury at all. It wasn’t enough to bankrupt our economy today; we need to pay for it by bankrupting our grandchildren and their children as well. Bernie Sanders couldn’t have imagined such an overwhelming victory over capitalism in his fondest dreams.
I heard President Trump say that it’s important to look at reopening the economy and assure that the cure isn’t worse than the disease, thank you Mr. President, better late than never.
Keep on the firing line.






No comments:

Post a Comment